Quote: "Like the observer above, many parents and critics express the opinion that computer
and video games are “mindless,” i.e. that kids don’t learn anything beyond hand-eye
coordination from the thousands of hours they spend playing video games. Other critics
express the opinion that video games impart only negative messages and, in the words of
one, “teach our kids to kill.” Still others assert that while players may learn “about the
game” they learn nothing “useful” about “real life.” (Prensky/2002)
Response: The author of the article disputes these assertions and I wholeheartedly agree with his reasoning. There exists a generational gap and a cultural lag when it comes to video games, especially using them for educational purposes. From personal experience, there is no doubt video games, along with being entertaining, also incite learning. Before my sons even insert a video game into their game system, they have already learned a great deal. They learned that advertisers try to suck you in with their commercials. They now thoroughly research games before they make a purchase. They learned about supply and demand. They know if they wait, prices on games will decrease with falling demand. They also learned there is value in taking care of their game because certain outlets buy used games. As far as what that have learned from actually playing the games, the list is endless. One example is a UFC fighting game they love to play. That doesn't sound like a game one would learn from, but surprisingly it contains much educational content. They create their own character and then they need to guide him through his career. They make decisions about time management. They are allotted so much time to prepare for a fight and have to decide which attributes to focus on to improve, all the while not letting other attributes decrease. They make economic decisions as well such as which sponsors to take on and how often to fight. They need to incorporate strategy as well as managing other characters in the game, such as their corner man. Playing this fighting game forces them to plan ahead, make good decisions and realize their actions, or lack of action, has consequences. All this from a simple fighting game. Perhaps the greatest lesson they will learn is the value of video games in relation to learning. They will not hesitate to incorporate video games in education.
Prensky, M.. "What Kids Learn That’s POSITIVE From Playing Video Games." www,markprensky.com. N.p., 2002. Web. 31 Mar 2012. <http://www.marcprensky.com/writing/prensky - what kids learn thats positive from playing video games.pdf>.
Here are five things schools could learn from Gardens of Time. (GOT)
1. Interaction. In GOT, you are constantly interacting with other players by visiting their gardens, exchanging gifts, and helping each other in order to advance through the game.
2. Customization. In GOT, the user is able to navigate through the game at their pace and choose which parts of the game to play and when. Incorporating strategy to build their gardens and move up though different levels. Upon receiving rewards, the user determines where to place them creating their own unique garden.
3. The Cycle of Expertise. As with most video games, GOT tasks become increasing difficult as the player advances through different levels.
4. Taking Relationships into consideration. Interacting with neighbors is vital to completing your garden in the game. Sending and receiving gifts allows one to build their garden more quickly and it is much more efficient.
5. Exploring. GOT game play is structured so the user may explore and learn at their leisure and pace. By exploring, the user becomes more competent and familiar with the knowledge to increase their levels.
Quote: "People have traditionally learned in school using books, more specifically textbooks which are characterized by the word ‘text’. Textbooks often contain “walls of text” that can be difficult for some to follow, especially as time progresses. It can also be difficult to find the important part of the text and place it into context. Video games have found a solution to this problem. Instead of placing a tutorial in the menu options of the game, tutorials and ‘help’ will often pop up when the time is right, placing that message into specific context. In addition to this feature, players are often able to pause the game and search for help when they desire. This pausing and reviewing is another form of placing knowledge into context, providing gamers with on-demand access to help."
Response: In effect, video games have advanced to a point where they provide one on one instruction to the individuals using the games. Although not a living and breathing "teacher", this concept allows for personalized instruction in areas where one is having more difficulty with. It is a force multiplier for educators, at a minimal costs. Once educational systems across the country embrace gaming as a legitimate form as education, software producers will compete for business by tailoring products to meet specific needs of the school systems. This will breed competition among software developer which will drive down prices while simultaneously enhancing the product.
Quote: "We know now that dyslexia is about so much more than just mixing up letters — that many dyslexics have difficulty with rhythm and meter and word retrieval, that they struggle to recognize voices and sounds. It’s my profound hope that our schools can use findings like these to better teach children who struggle to read, to help them overcome their limitations, and to help them understand that it’s not their fault." (Schultz, 2011)
Response: It is hard to comprehend how a child feels when they are unable to read, yet their classmates are proficient. To put forth the effort and have the desire to read, not being able to so and not understanding why, has to be devastating. Hopefully, advances in understanding dyslexia will result in some type of breakthrough that will allow us to conquer the problem.
Reference: Schultz, P.. "Words failed, then saved me." Newyork times. The New York Times, 2011. Web. 8 Mar 2012. <http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/04/opinion/sunday/with-dyslexia-words-failed-me-and-then-saved-me.html>.
I chose California's Velcro crop website to review:
Who? Has someone taken responsibility for the content of this Web site?
There is nobody that has taken credit. There is a person named Ken Uhlman but his background information is obviously distorted.
Is information about the author or organization clearly stated?
No, again, information on the author is distorted and obviously fake or intentionally vague. No group claims any type of responsibility.
Are there any links to in-depth information about the author or organization?
The link about the author is within the site and has obviously distorted information.
When:
Is it important that the information you're looking for be absolutely current? 1993 is listed as the date.
Is a reference date provided to show when the material was put online, or when it was last updated? A postscript at the bottom is dated 1996
Do the links work? No links except to author's bio.
What: Is the information biased in any way?
The information is presented in a way to mimic a legitimate site.
Does the site rely on loaded language or broad, unsubstantiated statements? Yes, the site makes a lot of claims that cannot be substantiated or are outlandish.
Is emotion used as a means of persuasion? Emotion is not interjected on the site.