I found this article very interesting and agreed with most of what was written. Linking literacy to socioeconomic status and identifying specifically how it hampers the process of learning to read is vital to anyone desiring to become a teacher. I am planning on teaching at the high school level, but if I had a second choice it would be teaching elementary students to read. The ability to read is, in my opinion, the most crucial skill learned in school. As this article points out, many under privileged students begin school at vastly different levels. Some do not any have the concept of reading, or literary skills. In effect, they start out behind students with literary skills and spend the remaining school years trying to catch up. Success in every other class is dependent upon reading. Many students begin in a hole they are never able to get out of. How can anyone enjoy education when at the most basic level, you struggle? The article also made me curios as to how dropout rates and reading ability are related.
What is literacy knowledge? Give examples of both print and non print literacy knowledge.
Concepts about reading children learn before starting school. Print: Reading from left to right.
Non print: People talk different than they write.
How do stereotypes interfere with literacy instruction?
It leads to thinking experiential differences are deficit differences.
How do schools and teachers contribute to poor literacy instruction in school?
Schools and teachers often do not recognize that some students do not have literacy knowledge or
mistake experiential differences with deficit differences.
What is the relationship between language, social class, and the denial of educational opportunity?
Children who speak improper English, or with a dialect, usually come from lower social classes. These
differences are often mistaken for deficit differences when they are nothing more than experiential
differences. This children are often deemed unable to learn or that they do not quite have the ability to
learn.
What can schools and teachers do to improve literacy instruction?
Teachers must view children from poverty as learners and accept their language as they way they learn.
How do you feel about use of the term "Proper English"?
Proper English is important to understand and used to communicate. There are times and places where
other forms of English is acceptable.
Part #2 NYT Article
Quote: "My own father spent his life backing up, apologizing for the space he took up in the world. He took the hillbilly stereotype to heart and all of his life believed that he was backward and inferior -- a despair I, too, have been trying to escape all of my life." (OBrien/2003)
I have had the good fortune of traveling and living in several places both in and outside of the United States. I have worked with and befriended many people from across the country as well, and I have never experienced that type of reaction to being from West Virginia as the author of this article suggests. Nobody has ever considered me less intelligent, civilized, or more violent just because of where I was born and raised. I am not denying there are stereotypes about West Virginians, but I have found most people use them jokingly or in good nature. Even if someone has assumed lower intelligence and less civility because of my association with the state, I am fairly certain, that just as with any other cultural or geographic stereotype, they were defeated by familiarity and understanding.
Proper English is important to understand and used to communicate. There are times and places where
other forms of English is acceptable.
Part #2 NYT Article
Quote: "My own father spent his life backing up, apologizing for the space he took up in the world. He took the hillbilly stereotype to heart and all of his life believed that he was backward and inferior -- a despair I, too, have been trying to escape all of my life." (OBrien/2003)
I have had the good fortune of traveling and living in several places both in and outside of the United States. I have worked with and befriended many people from across the country as well, and I have never experienced that type of reaction to being from West Virginia as the author of this article suggests. Nobody has ever considered me less intelligent, civilized, or more violent just because of where I was born and raised. I am not denying there are stereotypes about West Virginians, but I have found most people use them jokingly or in good nature. Even if someone has assumed lower intelligence and less civility because of my association with the state, I am fairly certain, that just as with any other cultural or geographic stereotype, they were defeated by familiarity and understanding.
Sources: (n.d.). The wild and wonderful whites. [Web Video]. Retrieved from http://www.youtube.com
No comments:
Post a Comment